Scott Pilgrim v The World review

Posted on 16 August 2010
By Miv Evans
  • Share:

Scott Pilgrim v The World was first a graphic novel series, then a video game, and now it’s a film. So with the latter being enriched by its predecessors, a most original work could have been created.

But, unfortunately, it wasn’t. What actually happened is someone wrote an uninteresting drama, added some sci-fi/superpower scenes, tossed in some sequential art and simply let them collide.

Rather like getting Pavarotti, Dolly Parton and Snoop Dogg to sing a line each of the same song and expect people to download it on iTunes. It’s just not going to happen.

Scott Pilgrim is 23, lives with his gay roommate and he’s in a band. He’s dating a 17 year old high school student but, when he meets Ramona Flowers, his allegiances change and he becomes obsessed with the girl with the color-coded hair.

But this isn’t going to be as simple as Scott hopes. Ramona tells him that if he wants to date her, he’s going to have to defeat her seven evil ex-boyfriends.

The film starts in a normal world, with hardly any reference to video games, which is pretty uninspired writing.

Scott, at least, should be obsessed and these games encroaching on his world, creating some kind of a build up rather than the monotony of going from normal, to superpower, to normal, to superpower, always at the same pace.

Scott is pretty wishy washy and his only goal in life is to find a girlfriend, which is hardly enough to drive a film.

And I don’t remember him duking it out with seven of Ramona’s exes, but then again, I wasn’t counting – but shouldn’t he have been? Or, if this is a game, shouldn’t the score be on our screens?

Something did start appearing in the bottom left towards the end but not for long enough to read so I imagine the filmmakers assume we all have superpowers of our own.